bargaining brief is a publication
from the Policy & Information Team. It aims to provide a concise
and topical news service for activists and staff engaged in representing
and bargaining on behalf of UNISON members in Scotland. Recognising
that not all activists have the access or time to read detailed
information we hope this summary format will be helpful. Further
information on any of the news items below is available from the
P&I Team and we welcome feedback on any aspect of this service.
Legal
Holiday pay entitlement whilst
on long-term sick leave
Trade union recognition – appropriate bargaining
units
Equal pay comparators
Proving 'mental impairment' under the DDA
Increased unfair dismissal award limits
Employment Rights
New rules on parental leave
Whistleblowers and contract breaches
|
Bargaining issues
Sickness Absence Falling
Stress Counselling
Stress and reduced productivity
Health & Safety
Employer liability for drivers
Equalities
Equalities Commission
Pay Gap narrowing in Scotland
AND
FINALLY . . .
What's
in a job title?
Contacts
list:
|
Legal
Holiday pay entitlement whilst
on long-term sick leave
The EAT (in Kigass Aero v
Brown) has confirmed that under the Working Time Regulations
1998 employees continue to accrue entitlement to paid holiday whilst
on long-term sick leave. Therefore, even when a worker's contractual
sickpay and SSP entitlements have run out they are entitled to 4
weeks' paid holiday per year.
Trade union recognition –
appropriate bargaining units
There's been some clarification
of what is meant by an 'appropriate bargaining unit' in an application
for compulsory trade union recognition. In R v Central
Arbitration Committee ex parte Kwik Fit, the Court held that
the CAC must base its decision on the most appropriate unit on the
location and nature of the workers seeking recognition. It said
'It is obviously no answer to a claim for recognition in Bolton
that there is a more appropriate bargaining unit in Liverpool'.
The CAC and the union had both previously argued that the CAC''s
obligation was to decide whether the bargaining unit proposed by
the union was appropriate; if it wasn't then the CAC should go on
to consider the employer's proposal. This decision overturns that.
Equal pay comparators
In South Ayrshire Council
v Morton, the Court of Session has confirmed that a comparator
for an equal pay claim doesn't have to come from the employee's
own workplace or the same employer. Where a collective bargaining
unit exists any employee who falls within that unit can be used
as a comparator. In Morton a female headmistress of a primary
school could use a male headmaster of a secondary school in another
local authority area as the comparator, since teachers' pay is negotiated
nationally.
Proving 'mental impairment'
under the DDA
A recent EAT gave useful guidance
on the sort of evidence needed to prove 'mental impairment' under
the DDA. In Morgan v Staffordshire University the
EAT held that it is not enough to plead just a catch all complaint
of 'stress' and then provide medical notes for the Tribunal which
may or may not diagnose depression or a similar condition; for a
mental impairment to meet the requirements of the Act it must be
a recognised clinical condition and proper supporting medical reports
should be provided.
Increased unfair dismissal
award limits
The maximum payouts for unfair dismissal,
if the dismissal takes place on or after 1st February
2002, have increased. The maximum compensatory award is now £52,600
and the basic award for unfair dismissal has risen by £10 per week
to £250pw.
top
Employment Rights
New rules on parental leave
As from 10th January
2002 all parents with children who were aged under five on 15 December
1999 are now entitled to 13 weeks off work (rather than just parents
of children born after that date). However, the leave is still unpaid,
must still be taken in blocks of a week or more and the parents
must have worked for an employer for a year before they are entitled
to parental leave.
There are special rules in place
for the parents who now qualify for leave under the
new rules. Parents of children born
or adopted between 15 December 1994 and 14 December 1999 are allowed
to count a period of continuous employment of a year or more
with a previous employer from 15
December 1998 towards qualifying service for parental leave with
their current employer.
Therefore, a parent of a child born
in January 1995 who had worked for 2 years for one employer between
March 2000 and March 2002 and then changed jobs now qualifies automatically
for parental leave with their new employer. They must take the 13
weeks leave by the end of March 2005.
Whistleblowers and contract
breaches
A recent EAT decision has shown
that workers with less than a year's service can potentially claim
unfair dismissal for alleging that their contract has been breached,
under the 'whistleblowing' protections. In Parkins v Sodexho,
the complainant said that he had been dismissed for informing his
manager about lack of supervision, which he claimed was an infringement
of his contract and therefore a 'protected disclosure' under the
the Public Interest Disclosure Act 1988 because it was an infringement
of a legal obligation. The EAT agreed with him. This decision increases
the options for people to claim unfair dismissal against their new
employer in the first year of their employment with them.
top
Bargaining issues
Sickness Absence Falling
Local Government employers have
reported that sickness absence has fallen for the second year running,
with the average absence now running at 9.6 days per employee.
This compares favourably with the
civil service and the NHS, but surveys shows a much lower level
in the private and voluntary sector.
Stress is still the most common
cause of illness at 20% with viral infections at 12.5%
Stress Counselling
A recent Court of Appeal ruling has indicated
that employers offering confidential counselling services to their
staff are less likely to be found liable for work-related stress
claims. The judge laid down guidelines (which reinforce the UNISON
Guidelines on Stress Management) for courts on stress claims and
threw out three cases for compensation totalling nearly £200,000.
The guidelines say that employees
should raise concerns over stress with their employers before they
take legal action but that management should be encouraged to recognise
the existence and causes of stress and take sensible steps to eliminate
it.
Stress and reduced productivity
In a further study, over 89% of
bosses do not regard stress as having a significant adverse impact
on productivity.
The NOP/Investors in People UK research
revealed that despite increased public awareness, employers did
not believe the effect workplace stress would have on organisations.
One fifth of employees on the other hand, claim that stress is the
single biggest barrier affecting their output.
Ruth Spellman Chief Executive of
IIP UK felt that it was time for employers to realise that stress
was often a reflection of a company's failure to support its staff
rather than an indication of an individual's weakness.
top
HEALTH & SAFETY
Employer liability for drivers
Employers with employees on the
road could face prosecution if they don't have clear safety policies
protecting staff who drive during working hours.
From 2003 the Health & Safety
Commission is proposed to apply rigorous health & safety laws
to on-the-road activities, including an accident report form enabling
police to assess the workload of commercial drivers. If an accident
was found to have been caused by dangerous driving due to onerous
employer demands, then the organisation could face prosecution.
The proposals would also allow the HSC to check on the training
and supervision of the drivers involved.
top
EQUALITIES
Equalities Commission
Consultation is currently under
way on government proposals to create a single Equalities Commission,
replacing the existing commissions for equal opportunities, race
and disability. In addition, there are rumours that the areas of
age, sexual orientation and religious equality are to be added on
to the remit of the current commissions.
Pay Gap narrowing in Scotland
The latest New Earnings Survey from
the Office of National Statistics shows that the pay gap in Scotland
is narrower than the UK average. Scotswomen now take home 83.2%
of the average male rate, compared to 80.6% the year before.
However, the Equal Opportunities
Commission in Scotland feels there is no room for complacency; they
have produced a separate report showing that women fill only 29%
of management positions in Scotland, compared with 30% across the
UK
top
AND FINALLY
A new survey finds that nearly half
of all employees believe a new job title could improve their happiness
at work. People should be as happy with a flash title as with a
pay rise, says Professor Cary Cooper Bupa professor of organisational
psychology at Manchester University. He feels it gives them a sense
of security and a marketable asset.
top
Contacts list:
Dave Watson
d.watson@unison.co.uk
Dianne Anderson
d.anderson@unison.co.uk
@ the P&I Team
14 West Campbell St
Glasgow G26RX
Tel 0141-332 0006
Fax 0141-307 2572
|